Complaints and Appeals Policy
ChemClass Journal is committed to maintaining transparency, fairness, and accountability in all aspects of its editorial and publishing processes. The Journal recognises that authors, reviewers, readers, and stakeholders may occasionally have legitimate concerns regarding editorial decisions, peer review processes, or publication ethics.
This policy establishes a structured mechanism for handling complaints and appeals in a consistent, impartial, and timely manner, in accordance with internationally accepted publishing ethics standards, including COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) guidelines.
PRINCIPLE OF FAIRNESS AND TRANSPARENCY
All complaints and appeals submitted to ChemClass Journal are treated seriously, confidentially, and with due consideration. The Journal is committed to ensuring that decisions are based on evidence, scholarly merit, and ethical principles rather than subjective or biased judgment.
The editorial process is designed to be fair, transparent, and accountable at all stages.
SCOPE OF COMPLAINTS
Complaints may be submitted regarding issues such as:
- Alleged errors in editorial or administrative processes;
- Concerns about delays in peer review or publication;
- Perceived bias or unfair treatment in editorial decisions;
- Concerns about reviewer conduct or comments;
- Allegations of ethical misconduct in the publication process;
- Issues related to communication with the editorial office.
Complaints must be based on factual concerns and submitted in a professional manner.
SUBMISSION OF COMPLAINTS
All complaints should be submitted in writing to the Editorial Office and must include:
- Clear identification of the issue being raised;
- Relevant manuscript or article details (if applicable);
- Supporting evidence or documentation;
- A clear description of the desired resolution.
Anonymous complaints may be considered at the discretion of the Editorial Office, particularly where serious ethical concerns are raised.
INITIAL REVIEW OF COMPLAINTS
Upon receipt of a complaint, the Editorial Office will:
- Acknowledge receipt of the complaint;
- Conduct an initial assessment of its validity and relevance;
- Determine whether the matter falls within the scope of editorial jurisdiction;
- Assign the complaint to the appropriate handling editor or committee.
Simple administrative issues may be resolved directly by the Editorial Office, while complex matters may require formal investigation.
SCOPE OF APPEALS
Authors may submit appeals against editorial decisions, including:
- Rejection of manuscripts;
- Major revision requirements perceived as unjustified;
- Alleged procedural errors in peer review;
- Concerns regarding reviewer bias or misunderstanding of the work.
Appeals must be based on scientific or procedural grounds and not on disagreement alone with editorial judgment.
APPEALS PROCEDURE
When an appeal is submitted, ChemClass Journal will follow a structured review process:
- The original editorial decision and reviewer reports will be re-examined;
- An independent editorial assessment may be conducted by a senior editor not involved in the original decision;
- Where necessary, additional expert review may be sought;
- Authors may be asked to provide clarification or additional information.
The outcome of the appeal will be communicated clearly and transparently to the author(s).
GROUNDS FOR UPHOLDING OR REJECTING APPEALS
An appeal may be upheld if:
- There is evidence of factual or procedural error;
- Reviewer comments were demonstrably biased or inconsistent;
- Important scientific considerations were overlooked;
- New information significantly affects the original decision.
An appeal may be rejected if:
- The original editorial decision is found to be scientifically justified;
- The appeal is based solely on disagreement with the rejection.
- No substantive evidence is provided to support the appeal.
Editorial judgment remains independent and is guided by peer review standards and journal policies.
ETHICAL COMPLAINTS AND MISCONDUCT
Complaints involving allegations of ethical misconduct, including plagiarism, data fabrication, authorship disputes, or research ethics violations, will be referred to the Journal’s Research Integrity or Ethics framework for formal investigation.
Such cases may require consultation with authors’ institutions or external bodies in accordance with COPE guidelines.
CONFIDENTIALITY
All complaints and appeals are handled confidentially. Information will only be shared with individuals directly involved in the resolution process, including relevant editors, reviewers, or institutional representatives, where necessary.
The identity of complainants will be protected where possible, particularly in cases involving ethical concerns.
TIMELINES FOR RESPONSE
ChemClass Journal is committed to handling complaints and appeals in a timely manner. While timelines may vary depending on complexity, the Journal will:
- Acknowledge receipt promptly;
- Provide interim updates where investigations are ongoing;
- Communicate final decisions as soon as reasonably possible.
Delays will be communicated transparently with appropriate justification.
FINAL DECISION AUTHORITY
Final decisions on complaints and appeals rest with the Editor-in-Chief or designated senior editorial authority, based on evidence, reviewer input, and journal policy.
Decisions are considered final once communicated, although exceptional cases involving ethical or legal concerns may warrant further review.
ABUSE OF THE COMPLAINTS PROCESS
ChemClass Journal reserves the right to disregard or close complaints or appeals that are:
- Vexatious, abusive, or repetitive without new evidence;
- Submitted in bad faith;
- Not supported by reasonable academic or procedural grounds;
- Intended to obstruct editorial processes.
COMMITMENT TO IMPARTIALITY AND ACCOUNTABILITY
ChemClass Journal is committed to ensuring that all complaints and appeals are addressed fairly, objectively, and without prejudice. The Journal upholds the principles of academic freedom, editorial independence, and research integrity in resolving disputes.
Through this Complaints and Appeals Policy, ChemClass Journal reinforces its commitment to transparent, accountable, and ethical scholarly publishing in chemistry and related disciplines.
