Information for Reviewers

ChemClass Journal recognises peer review as a fundamental component of scholarly publishing and an essential mechanism for maintaining the quality, credibility, and integrity of scientific literature. The Journal relies on qualified reviewers with appropriate subject expertise to provide independent, objective, and constructive assessments of submitted manuscripts.

Reviewers play a critical role in assisting the Editorial Board in making informed publication decisions and helping authors improve the quality, clarity, and scientific contribution of their manuscripts.

All reviewers engaged by ChemClass Journal are expected to conduct reviews in accordance with internationally accepted principles of scholarly publishing ethics, including the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

Role and Responsibility of Reviewers

Reviewers are expected to provide an unbiased, critical, and constructive evaluation of manuscripts assigned to them.

The primary responsibilities of reviewers include:

  • Assessing the scientific quality, originality, and relevance of submitted manuscripts;
  • Evaluating the accuracy, validity, and adequacy of research methods and analyses;
  • Identifying strengths and weaknesses of the manuscript;
  • Providing constructive comments that assist authors in improving their work;
  • Identifying potential ethical concerns, including plagiarism, duplicate publication, data concerns, or inappropriate citations;
  • Providing a recommendation to the Editor regarding the suitability of the manuscript for publication.

Reviewer recommendations should be based solely on academic and scientific considerations.

Reviewer Qualifications

ChemClass Journal selects reviewers based on their:

  • Demonstrated expertise in the relevant research area;
  • Academic qualifications and research experience;
  • Publication record in relevant scientific fields;
  • Understanding of research methodology and ethical publishing practices.

Reviewers should accept assignments only when they possess sufficient expertise to provide a competent evaluation.

Confidentiality of Manuscripts

All manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential documents.

Reviewers must not:

  • Share manuscripts or review materials with others;
  • Discuss manuscript content with individuals outside the review process;
  • Use information obtained during peer review for personal advantage or research purposes.

The content of unpublished manuscripts must remain confidential before and after the review process.

Objectivity and Fairness

Reviews must be conducted objectively, professionally, and respectfully.

Reviewers should:

  • Avoid personal criticism of authors;
  • Provide clear explanations for their comments and recommendations;
  • Distinguish between major scientific concerns and minor editorial corrections;
  • Avoid making judgments based on nationality, institutional affiliation, gender, ethnicity, professional status, or personal relationships.

Comments should focus exclusively on the scientific content and quality of the manuscript.

Conflict of Interest

Reviewers must disclose any potential conflict of interest before accepting a review assignment.

A reviewer should decline to review a manuscript if:

  • They have a personal, professional, or financial relationship with any author;
  • They have collaborated recently with the authors;
  • They have competing interests that could affect impartial judgment;
  • They feel unable to provide an objective evaluation.

The Editor will determine whether reassignment of the manuscript is necessary.

Timeliness of Reviews

Reviewers should complete evaluations within the timeframe provided by the Editorial Office.

If a reviewer is unable to complete the review within the agreed period, they should promptly notify the Editor so that alternative arrangements can be made.

Timely reviews contribute to efficient manuscript processing and a positive author experience.

Assessment Criteria

Reviewers should evaluate manuscripts based on the following criteria:

Scientific Quality

Reviewers should assess:

  • Originality and novelty of the research;
  • Importance and relevance of the research question;
  • Scientific contribution to the field;
  • Adequacy of experimental design or theoretical approach.

Methodology

Reviewers should consider:

  • Appropriateness of methods used;
  • Completeness of methodological descriptions;
  • Reliability and validity of results;
  • Suitability of statistical or computational analyses.

Results and Interpretation

Reviewers should evaluate:

  • Clarity and accuracy of results presentation;
  • Whether conclusions are supported by evidence;
  • Appropriate discussion of findings in relation to existing literature.

Presentation Quality

Reviewers should assess:

  • Organisation and clarity of manuscript structure;
  • Quality of figures, tables, and illustrations;
  • Accuracy and completeness of references;
  • Language clarity and readability.

Reviewer Comments and Recommendations

Reviewer reports should provide constructive feedback that assists the Editor and authors.

Comments should include:

  • Specific observations;
  • Clear explanations of identified problems;
  • Suggestions for improvement where appropriate.

Reviewer recommendations may include:

  • Accept without revision;
  • Minor revision;
  • Major revision;
  • Reject.

The final publication decision rests solely with the Editor-in-Chief or designated editorial authority.

Ethical Concerns During Review

Reviewers should alert the Editor if they identify concerns including:

  • Plagiarism or excessive similarity with published work;
  • Duplicate or redundant publication;
  • Fabrication, falsification, or questionable data practices;
  • Ethical approval concerns;
  • Inappropriate authorship practices;
  • Manipulation of citations.

Reviewers should provide supporting information where possible.

Use of Artificial Intelligence Tools During Peer Review

Reviewers must protect manuscript confidentiality when using digital tools.

Reviewers should not upload unpublished manuscripts, confidential manuscript content, reviewer reports, or research data into publicly available artificial intelligence systems or external platforms.

Any use of AI-assisted tools must comply with ChemClass Journal’s Policy on Generative AI and AI-Assisted Technologies in Scientific Writing and maintain confidentiality, accuracy, and ethical responsibility.

Reviewer Recognition and Contribution

ChemClass Journal values the contributions of reviewers to maintaining research quality and publication integrity.

The Journal may acknowledge reviewer contributions through appropriate recognition 

mechanisms, while respecting reviewer confidentiality.

Communication with the Editorial Office

All communication regarding manuscripts under review should occur through the official editorial channels.

Reviewers should not communicate directly with authors regarding submitted manuscripts unless specifically authorised by the Editor.

Reviewer Confidentiality After Publication

Reviewer identities remain confidential unless the Journal adopts an alternative, transparent peer-review model in the future.

Review reports and editorial correspondence remain part of the confidential editorial record.

Commitment to Ethical Peer Review

ChemClass Journal is committed to maintaining a fair, rigorous, and transparent peer-review process.

Through responsible participation by editors and reviewers, the Journal aims to ensure that published articles represent reliable, original, and ethically conducted research contributions to chemistry and related disciplines.