Policy on Generative AI and AI-Assisted Technologies in Scientific Writing
ChemClass Journal recognises the growing use of artificial intelligence (AI), including generative AI systems and AI-assisted technologies, in academic writing, data analysis, language editing, and research support activities. While these technologies may provide useful assistance in the research and writing process, their use must be governed by principles of transparency, accountability, and academic integrity.
This policy defines the acceptable use of generative AI tools in manuscript preparation and clarifies the responsibilities of authors, reviewers, and editors regarding AI-assisted content.
CORE PRINCIPLE: HUMAN ACCOUNTABILITY
Authors are fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and validity of all content submitted to ChemClass Journal, regardless of whether AI-assisted tools were used in the preparation of the manuscript.
Generative AI systems cannot be listed as authors or co-authors. Authorship implies intellectual accountability, which can only be attributed to human contributors.
All submitted manuscripts must represent the intellectual responsibility of the named human authors.
PERMITTED USES OF AI AND AI-ASSISTED TOOLS
ChemClass Journal permits the use of AI and AI-assisted technologies for limited and clearly defined purposes, provided that such use is disclosed appropriately.
Permitted uses include:
- Language editing, grammar correction, and readability improvement;
- Formatting assistance for manuscripts, references, and tables;
- Technical assistance in organizing or structuring text;
- Assistance in coding, data visualization, or statistical support (with human verification);
- Literature summarization or organization as a preparatory step, provided sources are verified by authors;
- Assistance in improving clarity of scientific writing.
All AI-assisted outputs must be carefully reviewed, validated, and approved by the authors before submission.
PROHIBITED USES OF AI
The use of generative AI tools is strictly prohibited for:
- Fabrication or generation of research data, results, or experimental findings;
- Creation of falsified images, figures, spectra, or scientific illustrations;
- Generation of references, citations, or bibliographic entries without verification;
- Writing entire manuscripts without substantial human intellectual input;
- Misrepresentation of research methods or outcomes;
- Concealing or replacing authorship responsibilities;
- Any use that compromises scientific integrity or introduces misinformation.
Any manuscript found to contain AI-generated fabricated or unverified scientific content may be rejected, retracted, or subjected to further investigation.
DISCLOSURE REQUIREMENTS
Authors must disclose any use of generative AI or AI-assisted tools in the preparation of their manuscript.
The disclosure should specify:
- The name and version of the AI tool used;
- The purpose of its use (e.g., language editing, data analysis support);
- The sections of the manuscript where AI assistance was applied;
- A statement confirming that all AI-generated content was reviewed and verified by the authors.
Failure to disclose AI usage may be considered a breach of publication ethics.
AI AND DATA INTEGRITY
AI tools must not be used to generate, manipulate, or alter research data.
All data presented in manuscripts must originate from actual research conducted by the authors or properly sourced secondary datasets.
Authors remain fully responsible for ensuring the authenticity, accuracy, and reproducibility of all data and results presented in their work.
AI AND REFERENCES
ChemClass Journal strictly prohibits the use of AI-generated references that have not been verified by authors.
Authors must ensure that all citations are:
- Real and traceable;
- Accurate and correctly attributed;
- Relevant to the content of the manuscript;
- Verified through reliable academic sources.
The inclusion of fabricated or hallucinated references generated by AI tools is considered a serious breach of publication ethics.
AI USE IN FIGURES, IMAGES, AND VISUAL CONTENT
The use of generative AI to create, alter, or manipulate scientific images, figures, spectra, chromatograms, or experimental visuals is strictly prohibited unless explicitly disclosed and scientifically justified.
Any AI-assisted visual content must:
- Be clearly labelled as AI-assisted where applicable;
- Not misrepresent scientific data;
- Be supported by original experimental or validated datasets.
Image manipulation that alters scientific meaning is unacceptable.
AI IN PEER REVIEW AND EDITORIAL WORK
Editors and peer reviewers must not use generative AI tools to:
- Evaluate manuscripts in place of independent human judgment;
- Upload confidential manuscript content into public AI systems;
- Generate peer review reports without critical human assessment;
- Disclose or expose confidential manuscript information to external AI systems.
All editorial and peer review decisions must be based on independent scholarly evaluation.
CONFIDENTIALITY AND DATA PROTECTION
Unpublished manuscripts, peer review reports, and editorial communications are confidential materials.
They must not be uploaded into public or unsecured AI systems, as this may compromise confidentiality, intellectual property, and publication ethics.
RESPONSIBILITY AND COMPLIANCE
Authors, reviewers, and editors are individually responsible for ensuring compliance with this policy.
Violations may result in:
- Manuscript rejection;
- Retraction of published articles;
- Notification of institutional authorities;
- Temporary or permanent restrictions on submission privileges.
EVOLVING TECHNOLOGY
ChemClass Journal recognises that AI technologies are rapidly evolving. This policy will be periodically reviewed and updated to reflect emerging best practices, ethical standards, and regulatory developments in scholarly publishing.
COMMITMENT TO ETHICAL SCHOLARLY PUBLISHING
ChemClass Journal is committed to ensuring that technological innovation supports, rather than replaces, human intellectual responsibility in scientific research.
The Journal supports the responsible use of AI as a tool for enhancing clarity and efficiency in scientific communication, while maintaining strict safeguards to protect originality, integrity, and accountability.
By submitting to ChemClass Journal, authors affirm that all AI-assisted contributions have been transparently disclosed, critically evaluated, and do not compromise the scientific integrity of the work.
