Editorial Independence Policy
ChemClass Journal is committed to maintaining the highest standards of editorial independence, academic integrity, and transparency in scholarly publishing. The Journal recognises that editorial independence is fundamental to preserving the credibility of the scientific record, ensuring public trust in research, and safeguarding the integrity of the peer-review and publication processes.
As the official scholarly publication of the Chemical Society of Nigeria (CSN), Zaria Chapter, ChemClass Journal operates under a governance framework that ensures editorial autonomy. While the Publisher provides institutional support, administrative oversight, and publishing infrastructure, all editorial decisions concerning the evaluation, acceptance, revision, rejection, correction, or retraction of manuscripts remain the sole responsibility of the Journal’s editorial leadership.
PRINCIPLE OF EDITORIAL AUTONOMY
The Editor-in-Chief has full authority and responsibility for the scientific content published in ChemClass Journal. Editorial decisions are made independently and are based exclusively on the scholarly merit of submitted manuscripts, including originality, scientific rigour, methodological soundness, significance of findings, clarity of presentation, ethical compliance, and relevance to the Journal’s scope.
Neither the Publisher, sponsoring organisations, affiliated institutions, advertisers, funding bodies, nor any external individuals or groups may interfere with, influence, or override editorial decisions. Editorial judgments shall not be affected by commercial interests, political considerations, personal relationships, financial factors, or institutional affiliations.
SEPARATION OF EDITORIAL AND BUSINESS FUNCTIONS
ChemClass Journal maintains a clear separation between editorial responsibilities and business operations. Editorial personnel are responsible for scientific evaluation and publication decisions, while administrative and business functions are managed independently through appropriate operational structures.
Financial considerations, including publication charges, sponsorship arrangements, advertising, institutional support, and other revenue sources, shall not influence the editorial assessment of manuscripts or decisions regarding publication. Manuscripts are evaluated solely on their academic quality and scientific contribution.
INDEPENDENCE OF THE PEER-REVIEW PROCESS
The Journal is committed to ensuring that peer review remains objective, fair, confidential, and free from undue influence. Editors select reviewers based on their expertise, experience, and ability to provide an independent scientific assessment.
Reviewers are expected to evaluate manuscripts impartially and to disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that may affect their judgment. Editorial decisions are based on the scientific merits of submissions and informed by reviewer recommendations, while remaining free from external pressure or interference.
PROTECTION FROM EXTERNAL INFLUENCE
ChemClass Journal does not permit external organisations, government agencies, political groups, commercial entities, professional associations, sponsors, advertisers, or other stakeholders to influence editorial decisions. Attempts to exert pressure on editors, reviewers, or editorial staff regarding manuscript outcomes are considered incompatible with the principles of editorial independence.
The Journal is committed to protecting editors and reviewers from inappropriate influence and supports their ability to make objective decisions based on established editorial policies and scientific standards.
EDITORIAL FREEDOM AND RESPONSIBILITY
Editorial freedom is accompanied by responsibility and accountability. Editors are expected to exercise independent professional judgment while adhering to ethical publishing standards, established editorial policies, and accepted principles of scholarly communication.
Editors are responsible for ensuring that manuscripts are handled fairly, confidentially, and consistently. Decisions must be based on evidence, scientific merit, and the Journal’s editorial criteria. Personal opinions, institutional interests, political considerations, financial gain, or ideological preferences must not influence editorial actions.
MANAGEMENT OF CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
Editors must disclose and appropriately manage any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that may compromise editorial objectivity. Editors shall recuse themselves from handling manuscripts where personal, professional, financial, collaborative, supervisory, institutional, or familial relationships could affect impartial decision-making.
In such circumstances, responsibility for the manuscript shall be delegated to another qualified editor who has no relevant conflict of interest.
ACADEMIC FREEDOM AND SCHOLARLY DEBATE
ChemClass Journal supports academic freedom and encourages the publication of scientifically sound research regardless of whether findings are novel, controversial, confirmatory, or challenge prevailing theories. The Journal recognises the importance of open scholarly discourse and seeks to provide a platform for constructive scientific debate conducted in a respectful, evidence-based, and ethical manner.
Editorial decisions shall not be influenced by whether research findings align with prevailing opinions, institutional positions, commercial interests, or political viewpoints.
CORRECTIONS, RETRACTIONS, AND ETHICAL OVERSIGHT
Editorial independence extends to decisions regarding corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions. Where concerns arise regarding the accuracy, reliability, or integrity of published work, the Journal reserves the right to investigate and take appropriate corrective actions in accordance with established ethical standards and publication policies.
Such decisions shall be based solely on evidence and ethical considerations, without regard to the status, reputation, affiliation, or influence of the individuals involved.
COMMITMENT TO INTERNATIONAL BEST PRACTICES
ChemClass Journal is committed to upholding internationally recognised standards of editorial independence and ethical publishing. The Journal’s governance framework reflects the principles of transparency, accountability, integrity, and scholarly excellence promoted by leading organisations involved in scholarly communication and publication ethics.
The Journal continually reviews and strengthens its editorial policies to ensure that editorial decisions remain independent, objective, and free from undue influence.
Editorial independence is central to the mission of ChemClass Journal and is essential to maintaining the trust of authors, reviewers, readers, and the wider scientific community. The Journal remains firmly committed to protecting the integrity of its editorial processes and ensuring that all publication decisions are guided solely by scientific merit, ethical standards, and the advancement of knowledge in chemical sciences and related disciplines.
