Manuscript Processing and Peer Review Guidelines

Overview

ChemClass Journal is a peer-reviewed, open-access scientific journal published quarterly by the Chemical Society of Nigeria (CSN), Zaria Chapter. The Journal publishes high-quality original research, review articles, short communications, and technical reports in Chemistry and allied scientific disciplines.

The Journal is committed to maintaining the highest standards of scholarly publishing through a rigorous, transparent, ethical, and unbiased peer review process that ensures the publication of scientifically sound and original research. 

Editorial Principles

The peer review process is designed to:

  • Ensure scientific accuracy and originality.
  • Improve the quality of manuscripts through constructive criticism.
  • Maintain the integrity of the scholarly record.
  • Eliminate bias through independent expert assessment.
  • Ensure compliance with international publication ethics.

The Editorial Board follows internationally accepted principles of publication ethics and confidentiality throughout the review process.

Type of Peer Review

ChemClass Journal operates a Double-Blind Peer Review System. Under this system:

  • Authors do not know the identity of reviewers.
  • Reviewers do not know the identity of authors.
  • Editorial staff remove all identifying information before sending manuscripts to reviewers.
  • All reviewers are expected to maintain complete confidentiality. 

Manuscript Submission

How Authors Submit Their Manuscripts

Authors must submit manuscripts electronically through the ChemClass Journal Online Submission System (Open Journal Systems).

Step 1: Create an Account

Authors should visit the journal website: https://chemclassjournal.com.ng

and register as an Author if they do not already have an account.

Step 2: Log In

After registration, authors should log into their account using their username and password.

Step 3: Start a New Submission

From the Author Dashboard:

  • Click New Submission
  • Read and agree to the Submission Requirements
  • Accept the Publication Ethics and Copyright policies
  • Continue to the next stage 

Step 4: Upload Required Files

Authors should upload:

  • Main manuscript
  • Title page
  • Evidence of Handling Fee
  • Figures
  • Tables
  • Supplementary materials (if applicable)
  • Cover letter (recommended)

The manuscript should be prepared according to the Journal's Author Guidelines.

Step 5: Enter Metadata

Authors should provide:

Step 6: Confirmation

Authors should review all uploaded files before clicking Finish Submission.

A confirmation email containing the manuscript identification number will be sent automatically.

Authors may monitor the progress of their manuscript through their online dashboard.

Initial Editorial Assessment

After submission, every manuscript undergoes an initial editorial screening.

The Editor-in-Chief or a designated Handling Editor evaluates whether the manuscript:

  • Falls within the scope of the journal.
  • Demonstrates sufficient scientific quality.
  • Complies with the Author Guidelines.
  • Contains all required sections.
  • Meets language quality requirements.
  • Complies with ethical standards.
  • Includes all required declarations.

At this stage, manuscripts may be:

  • Sent for peer review
  • Returned for technical corrections
  • Rejected without external review (Desk Rejection)

Common reasons for desk rejection include:

  • Outside the journal scope
  • Poor scientific quality
  • Inadequate originality
  • Serious methodological flaws
  • Plagiarism
  • Duplicate submission
  • Failure to follow submission guidelines 

Similarity Check

Before peer review, manuscripts are screened using plagiarism detection software.

The Editorial Office evaluates:

  • Similarity Index
  • Improper text overlap
  • Duplicate publication
  • Self-plagiarism

Where necessary, authors may be asked to revise or explain overlapping text before peer review begins.

Assignment to Handling Editor

Suitable manuscripts are assigned to an appropriate Subject Editor or Associate Editor with expertise in the manuscript's research area.

The Handling Editor oversees the review process until a final editorial decision is reached.

Selection of Reviewers

Normally, each manuscript is evaluated by at least two independent expert reviewers.

Reviewers are selected based on:

  • Subject expertise
  • Research experience
  • Publication record
  • Previous reviewing performance
  • Absence of conflicts of interest

Additional reviewers may be invited where opinions differ substantially or specialised expertise is required.

Reviewer Responsibilities

Reviewers are expected to:

  • Maintain confidentiality.
  • Declare any conflicts of interest.
  • Review objectively and fairly.
  • Provide constructive comments.
  • Support their recommendations with scientific evidence.
  • Submit reviews within the requested timeframe.

Reviewers must not:

  • Use unpublished data for personal advantage.
  • Contact authors directly.
  • Share manuscripts with third parties without permission.

Read more about information for reviewers here

Review Criteria

Reviewers evaluate manuscripts based on:

Originality

  • Novelty of the research
  • Contribution to scientific knowledge

Scientific Quality

  • Sound methodology
  • Experimental design
  • Statistical analysis
  • Data quality

Significance

  • Relevance to chemistry and allied sciences
  • Practical or theoretical importance

Presentation

  • Organization
  • Language quality
  • Figures and tables
  • Clarity of writing

References

  • Adequacy
  • Currency
  • Appropriate citation of previous work

Ethical Compliance

  • Ethical approvals
  • Research integrity
  • Animal and human research compliance (where applicable) 

Reviewer Recommendations

Reviewers generally recommend one of the following:

  • Accept
  • Minor Revision
  • Major Revision
  • Reject

Reviewer recommendations are advisory. The final decision rests solely with the Editor-in-Chief.

Editorial Decisions

Following peer review, authors receive one of the following decisions:

Accept

The manuscript is accepted for publication with little or no further revision.

Minor Revision

Authors address minor reviewer comments before acceptance.

Major Revision

Substantial revisions are required. The revised manuscript may be returned to the original reviewers.

Reject

The manuscript is not suitable for publication.

Revision Process

When revisions are requested, authors should submit:

  • Revised manuscript
  • Clean version
  • Marked version showing changes
  • Detailed point-by-point response to reviewer comments

Each reviewer comment should be addressed individually. Failure to respond adequately may result in rejection.

Final Decision

After satisfactory revision:

The Handling Editor makes a recommendation.

The Editor-in-Chief makes the final publication decision.

This decision is final.

Authors are notified accordingly and thereafter requested to pay the article publication charges (APC). 

Copyediting and Production

Accepted manuscripts proceed through:

  • Technical editing
  • Language editing
  • Copyediting
  • Typesetting
  • Author proofreading
  • Final publication

Authors approve page proofs before publication.

Confidentiality

Throughout the review process:

  • Manuscripts remain confidential.
  • Reviewer identities remain confidential.
  • Editorial discussions remain confidential.

Information obtained during review may not be used for personal research or advantage.

Conflict of Interest

Editors and reviewers must disclose any actual or potential conflicts of interest. Individuals with conflicts will not participate in editorial decisions regarding the manuscript.

Authors must disclose:

  • Financial interests
  • Institutional relationships
  • Personal relationships
  • Funding sources
  • Any competing interests 

Publication Ethics

ChemClass Journal is committed to the highest standards of publication ethics. The Journal does not tolerate:

  • Plagiarism
  • Fabrication of data
  • Falsification
  • Duplicate publication
  • Image manipulation
  • Citation manipulation
  • Undisclosed conflicts of interest
  • Authorship misconduct

Where misconduct is suspected, investigations will be conducted in accordance with accepted international publication ethics principles. 

Appeals

Authors who disagree with an editorial decision may submit a written appeal to the Editor-in-Chief. Appeals should provide clear scientific justification. The Editor-in-Chief may seek additional independent review before making a final determination.

Average Editorial Timeline

Although timelines may vary depending on reviewer availability and manuscript revisions, the Journal aims to achieve the following:

Stage

Typical Time

Initial Editorial Screening

1–2 weeks

Reviewer invitation and acceptance

1–2 weeks

Peer Review (Double Blind)

2–4 weeks

First Editorial Decision

1–2 weeks

Author Revision

2–6 weeks

Evaluation of Revision/Final Decision

1–3 weeks

Production and Publication

2–4 weeks

 

Contact Information

ChemClass Journal Editorial Office
Chemical Society of Nigeria (CSN), Zaria Chapter

Journal Website: https://chemclassjournal.com.ng
Online Submission Portal: https://chemclassjournal.com.ng/index.php/ccj
Email: support@chemclassjournal.com.ng

Read more about: Author's guidelines | Information for reviewers | Manuscript preparation guidelines | Manuscript submission workflow | Peer review process | Publication ethics |