Conflict of Interest Policy
ChemClass Journal is committed to maintaining transparency, objectivity, and integrity throughout the research and publication process. The Journal recognizes that conflicts of interest may arise when personal, professional, financial, institutional, or other relationships could influence, or reasonably be perceived to influence, the conduct of research, interpretation of findings, peer-review decisions, editorial judgments, or publication outcomes.
Disclosure and appropriate management of conflicts of interest are essential components of responsible scholarly publishing. ChemClass Journal requires all authors, reviewers, editors, editorial board members, and other individuals involved in the publication process to identify and disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that may affect their involvement with a manuscript.
PRINCIPLE OF TRANSPARENCY
ChemClass Journal considers transparency in conflict-of-interest disclosure to be fundamental to maintaining trust among authors, reviewers, editors, readers, and the wider scientific community.
The existence of a conflict of interest does not automatically prevent publication or participation in the editorial process. However, failure to disclose relevant conflicts may compromise the integrity of the publication process and may result in appropriate editorial action.
All disclosed conflicts are evaluated on a case-by-case basis, and appropriate measures are implemented to ensure fairness, objectivity, and independence.
DEFINITION OF CONFLICT OF INTEREST
A conflict of interest exists when an individual has personal, professional, financial, institutional, academic, or other relationships that may influence their ability to make objective decisions or judgments.
Conflicts may be actual, potential, or perceived.
§ An actual conflict exists where a relationship or interest directly affects an individual’s objectivity.
§ A potential conflict exists where circumstances could reasonably develop into a situation affecting impartiality.
§ A perceived conflict exists where an external observer may reasonably believe that an individual’s judgment could be influenced, even if no actual influence exists.
TYPES OF CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
Conflicts of interest may include, but are not limited to:
Financial Conflicts
These include employment, consultancy arrangements, research funding, grants, honoraria, investments, patents, royalties, commercial relationships, or other financial interests that may influence the research or publication process.
Authors must disclose all relevant financial support and relationships that may affect the interpretation of their findings.
Institutional Conflicts
These may arise from relationships between authors, reviewers, editors, and affiliated institutions, including institutional competition, collaborations, supervisory relationships, or organizational interests.
Academic Conflicts
Academic conflicts may occur due to direct competition, disputes, previous collaborations, intellectual disagreements, or professional relationships that may affect impartial evaluation.
Personal Relationships
Personal relationships, including close friendships, family relationships, mentorship relationships, or other circumstances that may influence objectivity, must be disclosed where relevant.
Professional and Other Conflicts
Other circumstances that may affect impartial judgment, including political, ideological, organizational, or professional commitments, should also be disclosed.
AUTHOR RESPONSIBILITIES
All authors submitting manuscripts to ChemClass Journal must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that may influence the research, interpretation of results, or presentation of findings.
Authors must provide:
- A conflict-of-interest declaration during manuscript submission;
- Complete disclosure of relevant financial support and relationships;
- Details of funding sources and sponsor involvement, where applicable;
- Clarification regarding the role of funders in study design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, and manuscript preparation.
If no conflict exists, authors should provide an appropriate declaration stating that they have no competing interests.
Failure to disclose relevant conflicts may result in manuscript rejection, publication correction, retraction, or other appropriate action.
RESPONSIBILITIES OF EDITORS AND EDITORIAL BOARD MEMBERS
Editors and Editorial Board Members must maintain independence and objectivity when handling manuscripts.
Editors must disclose any conflicts that may affect their ability to make impartial decisions and must withdraw from handling manuscripts where such conflicts exist.
Editors should recuse themselves from manuscripts involving:
- Their own research;
- Current or recent collaborators;
- Close colleagues or institutional associates;
- Personal relationships;
- Professional competition;
- Financial or commercial interests.
In such cases, another qualified editor will be assigned to manage the manuscript independently.
RESPONSIBILITIES OF PEER REVIEWERS
Reviewers must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest before accepting a review assignment.
Reviewers should decline to review manuscripts where:
- They have collaborated with the authors within a relevant period;
- They have direct professional or personal relationships with the authors;
- They have competing academic or commercial interests;
- They believe their objectivity may be compromised.
Reviewers must not use information obtained through peer review for personal, professional, or commercial advantage.
PUBLISHER AND BUSINESS RELATIONSHIPS
ChemClass Journal maintains a strict separation between publishing operations, financial considerations, and editorial decisions.
Commercial partnerships, sponsorships, advertising arrangements, institutional relationships, or other financial activities shall not influence:
- Manuscript evaluation;
- Reviewer selection;
- Editorial decisions;
- Publication outcomes.
The Publisher and supporting organizations respect the independence of the editorial team and do not participate in scientific decision-making.
DISCLOSURE PROCESS
Conflict-of-interest declarations must be provided:
- During manuscript submission;
- During revision where circumstances change;
- During peer-review where relevant;
- After publication if previously undisclosed conflicts are identified.
Authors, reviewers, and editors are expected to update disclosures whenever new information becomes relevant.
MANAGEMENT OF DISCLOSED CONFLICTS
When a conflict of interest is disclosed, the Journal may implement appropriate safeguards, including:
- Assignment of an independent editor;
- Selection of alternative reviewers;
- Additional editorial review;
- Requirement for additional disclosure statements;
- Publication of conflict-of-interest declarations alongside the article.
The purpose of conflict management is not to prevent legitimate research publication but to ensure transparency and maintain confidence in the scientific record.
UNDISCLOSED CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
ChemClass Journal considers failure to disclose relevant conflicts of interest a serious breach of publication ethics.
Where undisclosed conflicts are discovered before publication, the Journal may suspend manuscript processing pending clarification.
Where undisclosed conflicts are identified after publication, the Journal may issue corrections, expressions of concern, or other appropriate actions depending on the severity and impact of the issue.
CONFLICTS ARISING AFTER PUBLICATION
Authors, editors, reviewers, or readers who identify previously undisclosed conflicts affecting a published article are encouraged to notify the Editorial Office.
The Journal will assess the concern objectively and determine whether corrective action is required to maintain the integrity of the scholarly record.
COMMITMENT TO TRANSPARENT SCHOLARLY COMMUNICATION
ChemClass Journal is committed to ensuring that all research published in the Journal is evaluated and communicated through processes that are fair, transparent, and free from inappropriate influence.
By requiring comprehensive conflict-of-interest disclosure and responsible management of competing interests, the Journal strengthens trust among researchers, readers, institutions, and the broader scientific community.
ChemClass Journal remains dedicated to promoting ethical publishing practices and maintaining the highest standards of academic integrity in chemical sciences and related disciplines.
