Peer Review Policy

 

ChemClass Journal is committed to maintaining the highest standards of scientific quality, academic integrity, and scholarly excellence through a rigorous and transparent peer-review process. Peer review serves as a fundamental mechanism for evaluating the validity, originality, significance, and quality of scholarly research and plays a critical role in ensuring the reliability of the scientific record.

The Journal operates a Double-Blind Peer Review system, whereby the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from one another throughout the review process. This approach promotes fairness, objectivity, impartiality, and the independent assessment of manuscripts based solely on their scientific merit.

PURPOSE OF PEER REVIEW

The primary purpose of peer review is to ensure that manuscripts accepted for publication meet the Journal’s standards of scientific rigour, originality, methodological soundness, ethical compliance, and relevance to the scope of ChemClass Journal. Peer review also provides authors with constructive feedback aimed at improving the quality, clarity, and impact of their work.

Through the peer-review process, the Journal seeks to uphold the integrity of scholarly communication and advance knowledge in chemistry and related disciplines.

DOUBLE-BLIND REVIEW MODEL

ChemClass Journal employs a double-blind review process in which authors do not know the identities of reviewers, and reviewers do not know the identities of authors. Manuscripts are processed in a manner designed to minimise bias related to institutional affiliation, nationality, gender, academic status, professional reputation, or other non-scientific factors.

Authors are expected to prepare their manuscripts to support anonymous review by removing identifying information from the manuscript file and, where applicable, from the supplementary materials.

INITIAL EDITORIAL ASSESSMENT

Upon submission, all manuscripts undergo an initial editorial screening conducted by the Editor-in-Chief, Deputy Editor-in-Chief, Associate Editor, or designated Section Editor.

During this stage, manuscripts are evaluated to determine whether they:

§  Fall within the aims and scope of the Journal;

§  Meet the Journal’s formatting and submission requirements;

§  Demonstrate sufficient scientific quality for external review;

§  Comply with ethical standards and publication policies;

§  Show acceptable levels of originality based on plagiarism screening.

Manuscripts that fail to meet these requirements may be returned to authors for technical revision or may be declined without external review.

REVIEWER SELECTION

Manuscripts that successfully pass the initial editorial assessment are assigned to independent expert reviewers with relevant subject-matter expertise. Reviewers are selected based on their academic qualifications, research experience, publication record, and demonstrated competence in the manuscript’s subject area.

The Journal typically seeks evaluations from at least two independent reviewers. In cases where reviewer opinions differ significantly, additional reviewers may be invited to provide further assessment.

The Editorial Team endeavours to avoid conflicts of interest when selecting reviewers and may exclude individuals where impartial evaluation cannot be assured.

RESPONSIBILITIES OF REVIEWERS

Reviewers are expected to conduct objective, constructive, and timely evaluations of assigned manuscripts. Reviews should focus on the scientific quality, originality, methodology, data interpretation, significance of findings, clarity of presentation, and ethical compliance of the work.

Reviewers are expected to:

§  Maintain strict confidentiality of all manuscript content;

§  Provide evidence-based, constructive feedback;

§  Identify relevant published work not cited by the authors, where appropriate;

§  Report concerns about plagiarism, duplication, fabrication, falsification, image manipulation, or other forms of research misconduct;

§  Declare any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest;

§  Complete reviews within the agreed review period, or promptly notify the editorial office if unable to do so.

§  Reviewers must not use information obtained during the review process for personal, professional, or commercial advantage..

 EDITORIAL DECISION-MAKING

Editorial decisions are based on reviewer recommendations, editorial assessment, scientific merit, ethical considerations, and the Journal’s publication standards. The Editor-in-Chief retains final authority regarding all publication decisions.

Possible editorial decisions include:

Acceptance without revision;

§  Acceptance subject to minor revisions;

§  Invitation to revise and resubmit following major revisions;

§  Rejection with encouragement for substantial redevelopment and resubmission as a new manuscript;

§  Rejection.

 The Journal reserves the right to reject manuscripts that do not meet its scientific, ethical, or editorial standards, regardless of reviewer recommendations.

 AUTHOR REVISIONS

Where revisions are requested, authors are expected to respond comprehensively to reviewer comments and provide a detailed explanation of all changes made to the manuscript. Revised submissions may be returned to the original reviewers for further evaluation where necessary.

 Authors should address reviewer feedback professionally and scientifically, providing justification where recommendations are not adopted.

 PEER REVIEW TIMELINES

ChemClass Journal is committed to efficient manuscript processing while maintaining rigorous quality standards. Although review timelines may vary depending on subject area, reviewer availability, and manuscript complexity, the Journal strives to complete the initial review process within a reasonable timeframe.

 Authors will be informed of any significant delays that arise during the review process.

 CONFIDENTIALITY

All manuscripts submitted to ChemClass Journal are treated as confidential documents. Editors, reviewers, editorial staff, and other individuals involved in the review process are required to maintain confidentiality regarding manuscript content, reviewer reports, editorial deliberations, and publication decisions.

 Information obtained through the peer-review process must not be disclosed or used for personal benefit without explicit authorisation from the Journal and authors.

 CONFLICTS OF INTEREST IN PEER REVIEW

Reviewers and editors must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that may compromise objective evaluation. Such conflicts may arise from professional collaborations, institutional affiliations, personal relationships, financial interests, academic competition, or other circumstances that could influence impartial judgment.

 Where a conflict exists, the reviewer or editor must recuse themselves from handling the manuscript.

 ETHICAL OVERSIGHT DURING REVIEW

The Journal actively monitors submissions for evidence of plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabricated data, falsified results, unethical research practices, inappropriate authorship, citation manipulation, and other forms of publication misconduct.

 Where concerns arise during peer review, the Journal may request additional information, supporting documentation, ethics approvals, original data, or institutional clarification before proceeding further.

 APPEALS AGAINST EDITORIAL DECISIONS

Authors who believe that a decision was based on a misunderstanding of the manuscript or a procedural irregularity may submit a formal appeal to the editorial office. Appeals must be supported by a detailed justification and relevant evidence.

 All appeals are evaluated independently and objectively. Submission of an appeal does not guarantee reversal of an editorial decision.

 CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT OF THE PEER-REVIEW PROCESS

ChemClass Journal continually reviews and enhances its peer-review procedures to ensure alignment with international best practices in scholarly publishing. The Journal is committed to maintaining a fair, transparent, objective, and efficient review system that promotes scientific excellence and protects the integrity of the scholarly record.

 By submitting a manuscript to ChemClass Journal, authors acknowledge and agree to participate in the peer-review process in accordance with this policy.