Retraction, Correction and Expression Of Concern Policy

ChemClass Journal is committed to maintaining the integrity and accuracy of the scholarly record. The Journal recognises that published research must remain trustworthy, and when errors, ethical concerns, or misconduct are identified, appropriate corrective actions must be taken promptly, transparently, and in accordance with international best practices, including COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) guidelines.

This policy outlines the conditions and procedures for issuing corrections, retractions, and expressions of concern.

 PRINCIPLE OF SCHOLARLY INTEGRITY

The integrity of the scientific record is a core responsibility of ChemClass Journal. Published articles should reflect accurate, reliable, and ethically conducted research. When issues arise that compromise the validity or integrity of a publication, the Journal will act to preserve transparency and correct the record.

Editorial actions are guided by fairness, due process, and evidence-based assessment.

 CORRECTIONS (ERRATA AND CORRIGENDA)

Corrections are issued when honest errors are identified in a published article that do not invalidate the overall findings or conclusions of the work.

Corrections may be published in cases such as:

  • Minor errors in data presentation;
  • Typographical or formatting mistakes affecting clarity;
  • Incorrect author details or affiliations;
  • Minor methodological clarifications;
  • Errors in figures, tables, or supplementary materials that do not alter conclusions.

Corrections will clearly identify the original article and specify the changes made. The original article will remain part of the scholarly record, with a link to the correction notice.

 RETRACTION POLICY

Retraction is applied when findings are no longer reliable or when serious ethical or scientific misconduct is identified.

An article may be retracted under circumstances including, but not limited to:

  • Fabrication or falsification of data;
  • Plagiarism or significant overlap with previously published work;
  • Serious methodological errors invalidate conclusions;
  • Unethical research practices (including violation of human or animal research ethics);
  • Duplicate publication without disclosure;
  • Authorship disputes that compromise the integrity of the work;
  • Legal or ethical infringements rendering the article unreliable.

Retractions are issued to protect the integrity of the scholarly record, not as punitive measures.

 RETRACTION PROCEDURE

When a potential retraction is identified, ChemClass Journal will:

  • Conduct a preliminary editorial assessment;
  • Request clarification and response from the authors;
  • Where necessary, consult peer reviewers or independent experts;
  • Liaise with relevant institutions or ethics committees if required;
  • Make a final editorial decision based on evidence and COPE guidelines.

Retraction notices will:

  • Clearly state the reason for retraction;
  • Be linked to the original article;
  • Remain permanently accessible;
  • Be indexed and clearly marked as “Retracted”.

The original article will not be removed but will be watermarked or clearly labelled as retracted.

 EXPRESSION OF CONCERN

An Expression of Concern may be issued when there is credible evidence of a potential problem, but conclusive findings are not yet available.

This may occur when:

  • An investigation is ongoing at an institutional or legal level;
  • Evidence of possible misconduct is under review;
  • Serious concerns have been raised but require further verification;
  • Authors or institutions are unresponsive during the investigation.

Expressions of Concern serve as a temporary alert to readers while due process is ongoing.

 UPDATES TO PUBLISHED ARTICLES

Where appropriate, ChemClass Journal may update published articles without altering the original record in a misleading way. Updates may include:

  • Clarifications;
  • Additions of missing information;
  • Corrections of metadata or authorship details;
  • Supplementary explanatory notes.

All updates will be transparently documented and linked to the original article.

AUTHOR NOTIFICATION AND RESPONSE

Authors will be given the opportunity to respond to concerns prior to the final decision on correction, retraction, or expression of concern.

The Journal values fairness and ensures that decisions are based on verified evidence and reasoned editorial judgment.

Failure of authors to respond in a timely manner may result in the Journal proceeding with corrective action based on available evidence.

POST-PUBLICATION ACCOUNTABILITY

ChemClass Journal retains the right to investigate concerns raised after publication by readers, reviewers, institutions, or external stakeholders.

The Journal may initiate corrective action at any time if the integrity of the published work is in question.

TRANSPARENCY AND PERMANENT RECORD

All corrections, retractions, and expressions of concern will be:

  • Clearly labeled and permanently accessible;
  • Linked to the original publication;
  • Indexed where applicable;
  • Documented to preserve the integrity of the scholarly record.

The Journal does not remove published articles except in exceptional legal or ethical circumstances where removal is mandated.

COMMITMENT TO COPE GUIDELINES

ChemClass Journal adheres to the principles and flowcharts of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) in handling corrections, retractions, and expressions of concern.

These guidelines ensure that all editorial decisions are fair, transparent, consistent, and internationally aligned.

CONCLUSION

Through this Retraction, Correction and Expression of Concern Policy, ChemClass Journal reinforces its commitment to safeguarding the integrity of the scientific record. The Journal ensures that published research remains accurate, trustworthy, and transparent, thereby supporting the credibility and advancement of chemical sciences and related disciplines.